By Darby Turnbull
“Nothing should remain for the synthesising intellect to do in the face of a performance of a dramatic work of art; everything presented in it must be so conclusive that our feeling about it is brought to rest; for in the bringing to rest of this feeling, after its highest arousal in sympathy with it, lies that very peace which leads us to the instinctive understanding of life. In drama we must become knowers through feeling.” Richard Wagner, Opera and Drama
For the last ten years, BK Opera and their founders Kate Millett and James Penn have been making their mark on the Melbourne Art Scene with their innovative, grounded chamber iterations of classic opera. Without the grandeur and spectacle afforded by mainstage companies who have the benefit of government funding, BK’s stripped back works offer a unique opportunity to experience Opera with an intimacy and thematic resonance that’s rare and thrilling.
After directing a stunning iteration of Verdi’s Macbeth last year, Kate Millett brings her forensic attention to detail and eye for opulence to Wagner’s Tristan and Isolde. Reorchestrated for two pianos, conducted by Kelly Lovelady, Wagner’s score still feels startlingly modern and resonant. Wagner drops his heroine straight into her most dire emotions and lets the ugliness fester, bloom and wilt over the next three acts. Lee Abrahmsen’s Isolde more than proves her mettle as one of our leading Wagner sopranos. Proud, dignified and more than a little haughty, Isolde has the means, personality and righteous rage to wreak havoc on her enemies. She sings with formidable power but with a rawness that combines that indomitability of a princess and the wounded soul of a frightened woman.
Abrahamsen makes us feel every indignity she’s been subjected to, with bitter precision she recounts her already lengthy association with Tristan. Having already slaughtered her fiancé in battle, he washed up on her shore and not realising who he was she nursed him back to health before his real identity was revealed, unable to kill him she banishes him and demands he never return in exchange for his life. He reneges on his oath immediately, returning to abduct her as a Bride for King Mark of Cornwall. Her mother, a skilled herbalist, has equipped her with a selection of potions, including a deadly poison and a deadlier Love tonic. When we meet her Isolde plans to challenge Tristan to drink atonement with her in a murder/suicide. So far, so reasonable.
Tristan, sung by James Egglestone is a staunch, stoic soldier, whose honour is constantly valorised (his honour code doesn’t seem to extend to women) and Egglestone in contrast to the dominating presence of Abrahamsen plays him as straight forward, conflicted everyman who underestimates the extent of his own arrogance but still recognises the validity of Isolde’s wrath (not enough to actually do anything about it).
Alas, Isolde’s devoted attendant, Brangaene, switches the potions so they drink the love potion.
It’s key that neither the title characters show a hint of attraction to each other before they drink the potion. Even after, their intimacy (coordinated by Cohan) despite their passionate assurances is stiff and perfunctory.
This leaves the audience in the pleasurably uncomfortable position to explore the notions of free will, consent and the destructive power of sensuality.
With Isolde and Tristan chemically altered, it leaves the ‘sane’ characters around them to get infected by their stupor and start acting with as much volatility as they do.
Both Isolde and Tristan’s attendants show a devotion that far exceeds the platonic. Belinda Dalton as Brangene, whose intervention with the potions escalates the whole mess infuses her scenes with Isolde with an intense, passionate yearning that overrides her reason.
As Kurwenal, Henry Shaw’s virile baritone nearly dominates the second half as he cares for a wounded Tristan and valiantly (and it turns out misguidedly) fights for his honour. Like Brangene, there’s a distinct unrequited erotic charge running through their moments together.
As a contrast to the highly compromised intensity of the title characters, the purity and ultimate madness of Brangene and Kurwenal’s love adds dimension to the tragedy.
King Marke, only mentioned in Act 1 is brought gloriously to life by Warwick Fyfe. In another cruel irony, Marke is a sensitive and reasonable man and one of the least toxic examples of masculinity onstage. Basses are an endangered species and Fyfe’s instrument is in exquisite form (I heard he was recovering from illness); infused with tender mournfulness he suggests an alternative to the intense sensuality of the drug fuelled intensity of Tristan.
As with Macbeth Millett demonstrates her skill with merging the natural and unnatural worlds. A key component of Ishan Vivekanatham’s set and Oliver Hall’s costumes are the eruption and wilting of paper flowers during key emotional beats. One can only imagine what this creative team could do with a bigger budget, but the effects are still incredible; highlighting the artificial beauty and ultimate ugly core of the central ‘romance’.
BK Opera’s ascent is evident in the quality of work they continue to produce, attracting eminent and preeminent singers giving notable performances in intelligent, viscerally beautiful productions.
Image: Ben Fon / Fon Photography




